HRM 599 Final Exam

HRM 599 Final Exam

HRM 599 Final Exam

1. Question (TCO A)What are some of the legal and regulatory influences on discretionary benefits?

2. Question (TCO B) Give a brief overview of the main provisions of HIPAA.

3. Question (TCO C) Discuss the two forms of employer-sponsored disability coverage. Analyze the potential advantages of each for the employee and for the employer.

4. Question (TCO D) Your company’s CEO is interested in implementing a new dental plan for employees and has asked you to do some research. The CEO wants you to report back to him in 3 weeks with the following information: What are the three main types of dental care plans? Discuss each plan and make a recommendation for your company.

5. Question (TCO E) Discuss the various FASB rulings associated with retiree health insurance.

6. Question (TCO F) You have recently been hired as an employee benefit consultant and have been asked to recommend the establishment of either a defined contribution or a defined benefit plan. Given the following employer objectives, which type of plan would you recommend? Specify the type of retirement plan you would recommend. Explain how your recommendation would handle the employer's objectives. - Employer objectives include - majorityof employees are young - would like to encourage long potential service - concerned about providing retirement income, capital accumulation, and/or estate benefits concerned about limiting their funding costs and administrative expenses

7. Question (TCO G) Discuss the concept of "good business sense" of benefits communication and the primary objectives of an organization’s benefits communication program.

8. Question (TCO H) Family assistance programs help employees with caring for loved ones, both young and old. Briefly describe the three types of family assistance programs and their benefits.

Trident MGt301 full course 2014 latest

Trident MGt301 full course 2014 latest

Trident MGt301 full course 2014 latest


FUNCTIONS OF MANAGEMENT AND ROLES OF MANAGEMENT
Assignment Overview

For this first Case Assignment we will be looking at one of the world’s largest and most profitable corporations—Microsoft. With more than 100,000 employees and revenues of $80 billion per year, the company must carefully manage its extensive operations using all four functions of management. Maintaining its position at the top in a highly competitive industry requires careful strategic planning. Watching its operations in more than 100 countries also requires a strong control function. Also, its new CEO has some big shoes to fill following in the footsteps of Microsoft’s legendary founder and first CEO, Bill Gates.

Do some research on Microsoft and find out what you can about its planning, organizing, leading, and controlling. There are a huge number of articles out there on Microsoft, so be selective in what you read and focus only on articles directly relevant to these four functions. Here are some articles to get you started that cover aspects of these four functions at Microsoft:

Wingfield, N. (2013, Jul 12). Microsoft overhauls, the apple way. New York Times.

Nakashima, R. (2014, Feb 24). Microsoft CEO's collaborative approach contrasts bombast of former top exec.Telegraph-Journal.

Kim, J. (2013).Microsoft caught in FCPA spotlight. Newton: Questex Media Group LLC.

Menezes, B. (2014, Feb 06). Nadella to make MS 'tangible'.DNA : Daily News & Analysis
Case Assignment

Once you have finished doing your research on Microsoft, write a 3- to 4-page paper addressing the following issues:

1. Give at least one specific example each of planning, organizing, leading, and controlling at Microsoft.

2. Of these four functions of management, which one do you think is the most important for Microsoft’s strong success? Explain your reasoning.
Assignment Expectations

· Answer the assignment questions directly.

· Stay focused on the precise assignment questions; don't go off on tangents or devote a lot of space to general background materials.

· List supporting references and cite sources in proper format.

· Use appropriate writing style in essay form (organization, grammar, and spelling).

· See our guidelines for more detail on referencing and writing expectations:Student Guide to Writing a High-Quality Academic Paper

For the Session Long Project (SLP) this session you will be applying what you’ve learned to an organization that you are personally familiar with. Choose an organization that you are currently working for, have worked for in the past, or are otherwise personally familiar with. The papers that you will write for each module will require a fair amount of detail about the four functions of management, so it is important to choose an organization that you know well.

For this assignment write a 2–3 page summary explaining how your organization uses the four functions of management—planning, organizing, leading, and controlling. Make sure to have at least one paragraph devoted to each of these four functions and how your organization uses this function.

As a reminder:

Planning

During this process, organizations develop visions, goals, and objectives. They select strategies to reach their vision and meet goals and objectives.

Organizing

During this stage, organizations select organization design and structures that enable them to implement strategies.

Leading

This process refers to leadership, meaning the styles leaders use to fulfill their functions.

Controlling

This process monitors if strategies are on track and deadlines are met.
SLP Assignment Expectations

· Follow the assignment instructions closely and follow all steps listed in the instructions.

· Stay focused on the precise assignment questions; don't go off on tangents or devote a lot of space to general background materials.

· List supporting references and cite sources in proper format.

· Use appropriate writing style in essay form (organization, grammar, and spelling).

· Review Trident's “Writing Style Guide” for more detail on referencing and writing expectations. This guide is found under “My Resources” in the TLC portal.
Module 2 - Case
PLANNING
Assignment Overview

Tesla Motors is a unique company that manufacturers automobiles that run 100 percent on electricity. The company has received a lot of attention in the media. In spite of loans from the federal government and various tax advantages given to alternative fuel vehicle manufacturers, the company has had huge ups and downs and has come close to bankruptcy at least once. However, it has recently had enough success to repay a large loan from the government.

Initially Tesla only produced expensive sports cars that only the very rich could afford, but the company is now expanding into producing more cost-effective vehicles. In spite of recent successes, Tesla does face many hurdles. It is a relatively small company compared to the world’s major auto manufacturers. It faces competition from hybrid vehicles that are much cheaper, such as the Toyota Prius. Nissan has even come out with a relatively inexpensive fully electric vehicle—the Leaf.

Consumers may also be unwilling to face the inconvenience of a fully electric vehicle. There are few recharging stations compared with gas stations in the United States, and it takes far longer to recharge an electric vehicle than to fill a vehicle up with gas. So while there is large public support for environmentally friendly vehicles that will lower our dependence on foreign oil, Tesla faces many obstacles and must carefully plan its future in order to compete with the large auto companies and expand its consumer base.

Do some research on Tesla and the market for electric vehicles and see what you can find regarding Tesla’s strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats. Here are a couple of articles to get you started:

Tilley, P. (2014, Feb 20). Tesla Motors offers the epitome of automobile innovation.The Dispatch[Available on ProQuest]

Rechtin, M. (2014). Tesla's biggest test.Automotive News, 88(6603). [ProQuest]

Mandel, D. (2013). The great Tesla bubble.Automotive News, 88(6590) [Available on ProQuest]
Case Assignment

Once you have completed your research, write a 4- to 5-page paper addressing the following items:

1. Conduct a SWOT analysis of Tesla Motors with specific discussion about what you think are the main strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats facing Tesla.

2. Based on your SWOT analysis, give some recommendation for some specific steps Tesla should take in order to grow and remain competitive.
Assignment Expectations

o Answer the assignment questions directly.

o Stay focused on the precise assignment questions; don't go off on tangents or devote a lot of space to general background materials.

o List supporting references and cite sources in proper format.

o Use appropriate writing style in essay form (organization, grammar, and spelling).

o Review Trident's “Writing Style Guide” for more detail on referencing and writing expectations. This guide is found under “My Resources” in the TLC portal.
Module 2 - SLP
PLANNING

For the Module 2 SLP, you will be continuing to focus on the organization you selected for your Module 1 SLP and take a close look at strategic planning at this organization. You already gave a brief overview of planning at your organization for your Module 1 SLP, but now you will be taking a closer look at planning issues such as the mission, vision, and goals of your organization and also do some strategic planning and analysis of your organization.

For this assignment, first review the background materials carefully, then write a 3-page paper covering the following issues:

1. What are the main strategic goals of your organization?

2. Perform a strategic analysis of your organization using SWOT or PEST analysis, and make some recommendations for your organization based on your analysis.
SLP Assignment Expectations

· Answer the assignment questions directly.

· Stay focused on the precise assignment questions; don't go off on tangents or devote a lot of space to general background materials.

· List supporting references and cite sources in proper format.

· Use appropriate writing style in essay form (organization, grammar, and spelling).

· Review Trident's “Writing Style Guide” for more detail on referencing and writing expectations. This guide is found under “My Resources” in the TLC portal.
Module 3 - Case
ORGANIZING
Assignment Overview

Zappos Shoes, led by young CEO Tony Hsieh, is well known for its non-traditional approaches to the workplace. From the Background materials you should be familiar with traditional organizational structures such as the hierarchical organization, the flat organization, or the matrix organization. But CEO Hsieh plans an even more radical approach to organizing his online shoe retailing company, called "holacracy." This is radical new approach involves eliminating hierarchies and even eliminating job titles.

Many of you are used to working in a hierarchical organization, so as you can see, this new form of organization (or perhaps “lack of organization”) is a huge change over what most of us are used to. But for purposes of this assignment we must decide whether or not holacracy is likely to work for Zappos Shoes. This assignment reflects the radical new ideas of a younger CEO like Tony Hsieh as compared with more traditional structures found in the older and more established structures in Fortune 500 companies.

Here are some readings on Zappos and holacracy to get you started:

Frean, A. (2014, Jan 06). How holacracy killed the hierarchy in companies going flat-out for success,The Times[ProQuest]

Cook, D. (2014). Ready for holacracy? Zappos says it is.Benefits Selling.Breaking News[ProQuest]

Shiers, L. (2010, 03). Touring Zappos.Footwear Plus,, 52 [ProQuest]
Case Assignment

When you have finished researching Zappos’ current business model and holacracy, write a 4- to 5-page paper that answers the following questions:

1. What risks and challenges does Zappos face in implementing holacracy?

2. Overall, what do you think the chances are of holacracy succeeding at Zappos?

3. Do you think holacracy would work with a traditional Fortune 500 company? Why or why not?
Assignment Expectations

· Integrate readings on the concept of holacracy, Zappos Shoes’ organizational structure, and on traditional forms of organization structure.

· Answer the assignment questions directly.

· Stay focused on the precise assignment questions; don't go off on tangents or devote a lot of space to general background materials.

· List supporting references, and cite sources in proper format.

· Use appropriate writing style in essay form (organization, grammar, and spelling).

· Review Trident's “Writing Style Guide” for more detail on referencing and writing expectations. This guide is found under “My Resources” in the TLC portal.
Module 3 - SLP
ORGANIZING

For this assignment, write a 2- to 3-page paper analyzing aspects of Organizing at your selected organization. Some of the key aspects to focus on in your paper include the following issues:

1. How would you characterize the design of your organization? Is it flat, or multilayered? Is it a rigid hierarchy, or does it use alternative structures like team-based or matrix?

2. Is decision making mostly centralized at the top, or is there room for decentralized decision making at lower levels?

3. What kind of departmentalization does your organization use? Is it divided into functional divisions, geographical divisions, other divisions?

4. What is the typical span of control for managers in your organization? Is it broad or narrow?

5. Are employees highly specialized, or do employees have a wide range of tasks and responsibilities?
SLP Assignment Expectations

· Discuss all five elements of organizational design listed in the assignment instructions in the context of your organization.

· Stay focused on the precise assignment questions; don't go off on tangents or devote a lot of space to general background materials.

· List supporting references and cite sources in proper format.

· Use appropriate writing style in essay form (organization, grammar, and spelling).

· Review Trident's “Writing Style Guide” for more detail on referencing and writing expectations. This guide is found under “My Resources” in the TLC portal.
Module 4 - Case
LEADING
Assignment Overview

Few CEOs have been subject to as much criticism and attacks as Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg. Most famously, he was portrayed as the villain in the movieThe Social Network. Shareholders have complained about his leadership and failure to increase the stock price of Facebook, and others have claimed he is socially inept and too young and immature to be a CEO of a multibillion-dollar corporation.

However, in spite of this criticism Zuckerberg is inarguably one of the most successful CEOs and entrepreneurs in corporate history. The small project that he created while he was a college student has become world dominant in the social media business and is still growing and expanding. So in spite of all of the criticism he clearly has been a successful leader.

For this Case Assignment, do some research in the online library and find out what you can about Zuckerberg’s leadership style. Take a look at the criticisms as well as what you think he is doing right or what lead him to his strong success.

Here are a few articles to get you started:

Facebook's leadership: Time for an update? (Jun. 13, 2010).The Washington Post. [Available on ProQuest]

Bailey, B., & May, P. (2014, Feb 03). Facebook at 10: Zuckerberg pushing for change.Oakland Tribune. [ProQuest]

Lesley, C. T. (2012, Jan 27). Job at Facebook not for sensitive types.Toronto Star. [ProQuest]
Case Assignment

Once you have finished your research, write a 4- to 5-page paper addressing the following questions:

· How would you describe Mark Zuckerberg’s leadership style? Was it transformational, transactional? Both, or neither? Explain your reasoning.

· Consider both the positive and negative aspects of Zuckerberg’s leadership style. What is good, and what is detrimental to Facebook? Does the good outweigh the bad?
Assignment Expectations

· Answer the assignment questions directly.

· Stay focused on the precise assignment questions; don't go off on tangents or devote a lot of space to general background materials.

· List supporting references and cite sources in proper format.

· Make sure to use reliable and credible sources as your references. Articles published in established newspapers or business journals/magazines are preferred. If you find articles on the Internet, make sure they are from a credible source.

· Use appropriate writing style in essay form (organization, grammar, and spelling).

· Review Trident's “Writing Style Guide” for more detail on referencing and writing expectations. This guide is found under “My Resources” in the TLC portal.
Module 4 - SLP
LEADING

In this section of the Session Long Project, write a 2- to 3-page paper about one of your current or former leaders.

Do not write about yourself, even if you are a CEO or leader.

Analyze, using background materials, leadership styles and the leader's way of fulfilling functions of management. Key concepts to be addressed are:

· Did the leader empower the employees?

· Was the leader authoritarian?

· Was the leader transformational or transactional, or both?

· What is the vision the leader created for the company or organization you selected?

· How did the leader motivate the workforce?

· How did the leader communicate the company's vision or directions?
SLP Assignment Expectations

· Answer the assignment questions directly.

· Stay focused on the precise assignment questions; don't go off on tangents or devote a lot of space to general background materials.

· List supporting references and cite sources in proper format

· Use appropriate writing style in essay form (organization, grammar, and spelling).

· Review Trident's “Writing Style Guide” for more detail on referencing and writing expectations. This guide is found under “My Resources” in the TLC portal.
Module 5 - Case
CONTROLLING
Assignment Overview

Of course having solid control processes is essential for any successful organization. Some organizations like to seek formal recognition for their control functions through independent certifications such as ISO 9000. In order to receive ISO certification, you need to extensively follow and document a long list of published standards and then have an outside evaluator certify that you are meeting these standards.

ISO certification has both proponents and critics. Proponents argue that meeting ISO standards through certification will improve organizational control functions and also help signal to the outside world that you are running a solid operation with high standards. However, critics point to the huge amount of time and money spent on documentation that may be excessive. Critics also say that ISO focuses on documentation of processes rather than the actual quality/efficiency of the process.

For this assignment, first read up on ISO certification and examine the arguments both for and against it. Then read up on a new start-up company called Clinkle and consider whether or not ISO 9000 would be appropriate for this new company to seek. Clinkle is new online payment company that has received a lot of media attention recently but has also had its ups and downs. It has raised a lot of money from investors but is still at an early stage with no revenue yet.

Here are some articles on ISO certification to get you started:

Seddon, J. (1997). Ten arguments against ISO 9000,Managing Service Quality7(4), pp. 162-168. [ProQuest]

Wahid, R., & Corner, J. (2009). Critical success factors and problems in ISO 9000 maintenance.

The International Journal of Quality & ReliabilityManagement 26 (9), pp. 881-893.

Here are some articles on Clinkle to get you started:

Smart money follows mobile payment app Clinkle (July 4, 2013).Irish Times, Dublin [ProQuest]

Clinkle raises $25 million in seed financing as it prepares to change the way people transact. (June 27, 2013).Business Wire, New York [ProQuest]
Case Assignment

After doing research and carefully considering whether or not ISO certification is the right option for Clinkle, write a 4- to 5-page paper answering the following questions:

1. What aspects of the control function of management do you think should be the most important to Clinkle?

2. What would be the main benefits to Clinkle of obtaining ISO certification?

3. What would be the main disadvantages to Clinkle of obtaining ISO certification?

4. Overall, should Clinkle invest time and money in ISO certification, or are the resources better spent on other ways to maintain control systems?
Assignment Expectations

· Answer the assignment questions directly.

· Stay focused on the precise assignment questions; don't go off on tangents or devote a lot of space to general background materials.

· List supporting references and cite sources in proper format.

· Use reliable and credible sources as your references. Articles published in established newspapers or business journals/magazines are preferred. If you find articles on the Internet, make sure they are from a credible source.

· Use appropriate writing style in essay form (organization, grammar, and spelling).

· Review Trident's “Writing Style Guide” for more detail on referencing and writing expectations. This guide is found under “My Resources” in the TLC portal.
Module 5 - SLP
CONTROLLING

For this final SLP you will be looking closely at the control function of management within your organization. All organizations have numerous methods of control, but think carefully about what control mechanisms are most vital for your organization’s success. Then write a 2- to 3-page paper answering the following question:

· What control mechanisms at your organization are (or should be) the most useful or important for the success of your organization?

Focus in particular on the core technologies of the organization as applied to the control function of management. You can discuss control efforts and strategies already utilized by your company, and/or make recommendations that you believe would be useful for your organization to consider.

Begin your essay with a thesis statement in the introductory paragraph that identifies what you consider to be the key organizational control efforts that are (or would be) important to the success of your organization, and then develop a persuasive essay to support your thesis.

Remember to use background readings to support your key arguments and to cite and reference your sources. Your goal is to convince your professor, who will require some well-reasoned and well-supported arguments. Actual examples of control and accountability systems in action and how they work in your organization will also help to add support to your arguments, but you need to go beyond just being descriptive and provide some convincing arguments in favor of your position.
SLP Assignment Expectations

· Answer the assignment questions directly and provide clear arguments in favor of your answer.

· Stay focused on the precise assignment questions; don't go off on tangents or devote a lot of space to summarizing general background material.

· List supporting references and cite sources in proper format, including in-text citations.

· Use appropriate writing style in essay form (organization, grammar, and spelling).

· Review Trident's “Writing Style Guide” for more detail on referencing and writing expectations. This guide is found under “My Resources” in the TLC portal.
te

What cultural factors must U.S

What cultural factors must U.S

 What cultural factors must U.S. sports franchises overcome to increase popularity abroad? Why?
How can franchises ensure their products are appropriate for international markets?
Should governments protect their industries by placing tariffs on imported products? Why? Why not?
Include APA-style in-text citations as well as a reference section. 

synopsis

synopsis

350- to 700-word synopsis with the following element:


A description of how a specific business requirement would drive the project's creation and use

Note: Riordan Manufacturing is one of the Virtual Organizations. 


Riordan Manufacturing
Riordan manufacturing has been an electric fan manufacturer in china since 2000. They produce fans on forecast demands taking average sales data from the previous three years.
Flow diagram:
The following diagram below is the process flow diagram pictured below-














The process shows how the information system flows and major component are connected to each other. The process starts from motor and polymer supplies from the supplier and they are stocked in the inventories. The production is reduced to 93 percent to its original ones because of the non equilibrium between the required and supplied motor. The polymer and motors are used as raw materials in the supply chain. The polymers are melted and they are used to form the part of  the fan and major components like the housing of the fan. The fan is then assembled using plastic parts and the motor is purchased. The assembled fans are brought to the supply management from there and they are being moved to the distributers and the fans are shipped to the customers.
Proposal for business process change and diagram
Supply changes can be made to make a more efficient flow control. The proposed changes may include outsourcing the motors and polymer inventories. This will reduce the headache of managing stocks in the respective inventories so that focus can be made on production rather than on input and output on these inventories. Another change is to add a total quality management before supplying it to the customers and also the purchasing of raw material from the countries providing it in less cost. This will give the ultimate product in less incurred manufacturing price. 
The new system after these changes can be as followed-

















Internet and mobile access component of the system
The Riordan Manufacturing unified system makes it possible to secure the information. It focuses to make authorized access to its master database which can’t be accessed by anyone who doesn’t have the authority to access it. It also works through virtual private channels that can be accessed from a distance and can be controlled by using a tablet or mobile device. The data is centralized and the employees can have its access via virtual private channels which is a private network of the organization designed for the secured transfer of its information. Thus, the data can be easily updated by the employees and is only then saved successfully in the master database. The employee can be anywhere; at head office, at home or maybe even travelling and still this person can access and work, by signing into his account in the company’s private intranet network.
The centralized server of the Riordan manufacturing unified systems is located at its command center, and the employees access it through the internet. A centralized server provides single point admittance to all the employees’ irrespective of their location. The advantage of having a single point access is that if in case it fails, than it can be easily sorted out and maintained by IT professionals of the company. 
The users are also connected through this network by having a client login. This can be done easily without any extra efforts as the users are functioning outside of the company can easily connect to this network through their login accounts.  

References:
For completing the above questions on inventory management system, has been researched and used below considerable references for accurate information:
•	Chase, Richard B., Jacobs, F. R., &Aquilano, Nichlas J. (2006). Operations management for competitive advantage (11th ed.). New York: McGraw-Hill.
•	Krajewski, Lee J., &Ritzman, Larry P. (2005), Operations Management: Processes and Value Chains. Upper Saddle River, New Jersey: Prentice Hall.
•	University of Phoenix (2009). Riordan manufacturing virtual organization. Retrieved September 15, 2009, from Apollo Group, Inc., Week Four, OPS571- Operations Management.



Week 9 Discussion for BUS 508

Week 9 Discussion for BUS 508

Could you help me answer this questions?

Week 9 Discussion for BUS 508
From the case study and e-Activity, determine the importance of bankers having good working relationships with their clients. Support your response with two (2) examples that illustrate such importance.

From the scenario, examine the four (4) main accounting statements and determine which statement you believe to be the most critical in understanding a company’s current financial position. Provide a rationale for your response

Management Dynamics

Management Dynamics

Management Dynamics

Management Dynamics
Purpose
This written assessment is the first of two, and it provides students with an exercise to assist in their understanding of two important areas of enquiry in management, viz.: the issues, concepts, themes and principles associated with business ethics and ethical practice within organisations and with the roles that leaders and their leadership, particularly ethical leadership, can have on an organisation developing, maintaining or further improving its own ethical culture.As indicated in the lecture on business ethics (and corporate social responsibility) this issue is attracting more and more attention by large organisations in terms of what their customers, other stakeholders and the general public think about them.How do organisations go about putting in place and then embedding a socially responsible agenda and an ethical culture?It would seem that the organisation’s leaders have a role to play; but do organisations with ethical cultures create ethical leaders or do ethical leaders create, develop and embed ethical cultures into organisations?In the lecture on leaders and leadership there was a distinction made between the leaders who is a person with certain characteristics and traits and their leadership which is an outward expression of the activities and acts that these leaders have with their followers.So are leaders with high moral identity the only ones that can express ethical leadership or are leaders and their leadership not so closely coupled?These are some of the issues that you will need to consider when responding to the more specific questions outlined below in terms of your response to this assessment on ethical leadership.In addition, this written assignment provides you with an opportunity to demonstrate your level of information literacy, and your ability to present a cogent and coherent piece of writing that includes appropriate critical analysis relevant to what is outlined below in terms of this assessment.THAT IS, MERELY REPORTING WHAT OTHERS SAY DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN EFFECTIVE ANSWER TO THIS ASSESSMENT. In your critical analysis you should consider the views of others and then argue on what you consider is their contribution in terms of ethical leadership.Completing this assignment will assist you to achieve learning outcomes 1, 2, and 3 shown in the unit outline.
Assessment
The importance of ethical leadership is a subject of interest in current management and leadership research.To some extent this has been driven by what has been seen as an on-going sequence of large, dominant and indeed global organisations behaving badly since around the turn of this century.Many of these organisations were financial institutions involved in quite questionable lending practices that ultimately led to the global financial crisis and in some cases to their own demise.It is contended that if these organisations had had a more ethical culture then the practices by a few senior managers may not have led to either their demise or their significant loss of corporate reputation. With hindsight possibly leaders with high moral values and good ethical leadership could have made a difference to the outcomes suffered by these organisations.Based on the discussion in the lectures on leaders and leadership as well as on corporate social responsibility and business ethics and the discussions that you had in the Week 2 and the Week 4 tutorials you are develop an essay about ethical leadership that addresses the following questions:
Do you believe that leaders are hard wired in terms of their ethical values and so do not or cannot change; or are leaders able to be flexible so at times will they display ethical standards and ethical leadership while at others maybe not?
Does an ethical leader have to be both a ‘moral person’ as well as a ‘moral manager’?
Is it easier to act unethically and express unethical leadership towards followers than it is to act ethically and express ethical leadership?For example, if unethical leadership and the acts related to this leadership rely on not being found out how realistic is this presumption?Is it the case that in the end you are always found out?
What role do think Rupert Murdoch played in establishing a culture within News Corporation that ultimately led its employees to engage in the practice of phone hacking?Do you consider Rupert Murdoch to be an unethical leader?
When looking at the statements or letters from your ASX-listed corporation’s Chief Executive Officer (or Managing Director) and Chairman, what inferences can you make about whether or not these people demonstrate ethical leadership within their organisation?
Your response MUST include discussion for the following sources, viz.:
Brown, ME & Mitchell, MS 2010, 'Ethical and Unethical Leadership: Exploring New Avenues for Future Research', Business Ethics Quarterly, Vol. 20, No. 4, October, pp. 583-616.
Amernic, J & Craig, R 2013, 'Leadership Discourse, Culture, and Corporate Ethics: CEO-speak at News Corporation', Journal of Business Ethics, Vol. 118, No. 2, pp. 379–394.
In addition to the required sources shown above, you should use AT LEAST TWO other references that you have found.A superior answer will also include some real world examples as part of the evidence that supports your claims and arguments.The format of this assessment item should follow a discussion essay format with a brief introduction, a body and a brief conclusion
You also need to support any claims that you make by using relevant research literature, concentrating on peer-reviewed or scholarly sources.Note that newspaper articles and Wikipedia are not considered scholarly sources due to issues about peer review of the material presented. However, you can use newspaper articles and Wikipedia to obtain a general understanding on a topic that you are researching.Where scholarly sources are used then appropriate citing and referencing of these sources should be completed as part of your submission.
Length
1000 words (± 100 words).Given the short length of this assessment item you should aim to be clear and concise in your writing in order to adhere to the word limit. Avoid lengthy descriptions, particularly of any material presented in lectures, in your text or from other sources.Do not use direct quotations but rather briefly paraphrase what is discussed in your sources.Note this word count does NOT include the words used to compile your ‘References’ section at the end of your submission.
Format
Given the assessment asks for a response to specific questions, it is not strictly a discussion essay but you still need to follow the essay format for this assessment. As stated above, acknowledgement of any information sources must occur through using an in-text citation as well as a reference entry in the ‘References’ section at the end of the essay for each source used.
Presentation
Make sure that you insert your assignment into this assignment template before uploading to the Turnitin assignment drop box.
As you are adopting an essay format for this assessment, you should NOT use headings or sub-headings.
Entries should be put into the footer where requested by this template.
The font to be used for this assignment is either Arial or Times New Roman script, 12 point font size, 1.5 line spacing, and left justified.
You also need to familiarise yourself with the Academic Misconduct Policy regarding plagiarism and collusion.

child development

child development

For this assignment you will locate and apply several scholarly resources related to identity development during adolescence and develop a handout (2 pages) of key points for a formal group; high school guidance counselors, parents, or people who work with adolescents. Your handout should explain identity development at this stage and provide a general guide. Be creative with this assignment but be sure to cover identity development well via the scholarly resources you locate. You may use bullet points and a brief description of each resource vs. standard essay format. Always cite as needed and provide a reference page at the end.

I have collected a few resources to help you get started:

    Erik Erikson’s Theory of Identity Development
    Adolescent Identity
    Fuligni, A. J., & Eccles, J. S. (1991). Early adolescent peer-orientation and parent-child relationships.
    Separation-Individuation

The main reason President Harry Truman did not realize that the Japanese government was interested in negotiating a peace settlement just before the atomic bomb was dropped on Hiroshima is because?

The main reason President Harry Truman did not realize that the Japanese government was interested in negotiating a peace settlement just before the atomic bomb was dropped on Hiroshima is because?

The main reason President Harry Truman did not realize that the Japanese government was interested in negotiating a peace settlement just before the atomic bomb was dropped on Hiroshima is because? 

leadership issues

leadership issues

what are the leadership issues on this case?

10-104
Rev: November 9, 2010
This case was prepared by Cate Reavis, Manager, MIT Sloan Teaching Innovation Resources (MSTIR).
Copyright © 2010, Massachusetts Institute of Technology. This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-
Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 Unported License. To view a copy of this license visit
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/ or send a letter to Creative Commons, 171 Second Street, Suite 300, San
Francisco, California, 94105, USA.
Turnaround and Transformation: Leadership and Risk at
Boston’s Institute of Contemporary Art
Cate Reavis
On February 9, 2009, Shepard Fairey, a renowned street artist known for his iconic red, white and
blue, “hope”, “change”, and “progress” posters of Barack Obama that were used in the president’s
election campaign, was on his way to an opening night party for his “Supply and Demand” exhibition
at Boston’s Institute of Contemporary Art when he was arrested on an outstanding warrant outside the
front door. Fairey had failed to appear in court three days earlier on a vandalism charge dating back to
2000.
While the arrest interrupted the opening night’s festivities—and was a definite downer for the nearly
800 people who were awaiting Fairey’s arrival, some of whom had purchased tickets on Craig’s List
for $5001—it did nothing to dampen public enthusiasm for Fairey’s exhibit. Between February and
the exhibition’s closing in August, 130,000 people attended the show.
In some sense, the Fairey incident was great PR for the ICA, an institution that had gone through an
enormous transformation under its Director, Jill Medvedow. When Medvedow arrived in 1998, the
ICA had no money, few members, no permanent collection, and, on a good year, clocked 25,000
visitors. Operating out of an old police station on Boylston Street, it was hardly a must-see cultural
destination in Boston. It was considered less a museum and more an “insider’s art club”.2
By the time of Fairey’s exhibition, the ICA was, quite literally, in a very different place. In 2006 the
museum celebrated the grand opening of its new $51 million building, located on highly coveted
1 Milton Valencia, “Street Artist Arrested on Way to Event at ICA,” The Boston Globe, February 7, 2009.
2 Geoff Edgers, “Big Draw,” The Boston Globe, July 19, 2009.
TURNAROUND AND TRANSFORMATION: LEADERSHIP AND RISK AT BOSTON’S INSTITUTE OF
CONTEMPORARY ART
Cate Reavis
NOVEMBER 9, 2010 2
waterfront property in South Boston where, over the years, several high-end commercial developers
had failed in their building attempts.
Medvedow’s ability to bring change to an organization that had no power, involved being disciplined,
getting people to believe in an idea, and taking many, many risks.
Contemporary Art in Boston
Up until the late 1920s, modern art in Boston, and throughout the United States, struggled to be taken
seriously. In 1911 the director of Harvard University’s Fogg museum summed up the general feeling
about contemporary art at the time: “In having exhibitions of the work of living men we may subject
ourselves to various embarrassments.” By the late 1920s, a group of Harvard undergraduates set out
to challenge this viewpoint by forming the Harvard Society of Contemporary Art as a place where the
work of living men could be viewed.3 In 1936 the Society became the Boston Museum of Modern Art
and in 1948 the museum changed its name to the Institute of Contemporary Art. For more than 50
years, the ICA was the only place in Boston dedicated to contemporary art.
Unlike other styles of art, contemporary art, which included visual exhibitions, music, film, video and
performance created by living artists, had never caught on in Boston like it had in other cities, most
notably New York and San Francisco. According to Medvedow, there were a number of theories
behind this:
When you look at the ecology of what makes a vibrant contemporary art scene, you need to have
several different components that all interact with one another. There need to be art schools and a
strong artist community where work is created and ideas are exchanged. You need collectors,
galleries and institutions that acquire, present, sell, and display that work. Historically, Boston
lacked many of these components, never sustaining a critical mass of contemporary art activity
and, as a result, these gaps prevented the growth of a healthy contemporary art environment in
Boston.
Added to the ecology argument was the fact that there had been little private and public sector
investment in the arts in Boston, particularly contemporary. Municipal spending for the arts in Boston
was far less than what was spent in four dozen other cities in the United States and, on a broader
scale, Massachusetts ranked 50th among the states for per capita philanthropy.4 As Medvedow
remarked, “A lot of Boston’s wealth was built on conserving it and less on creating it.” And then
there was the New York factor. As Medvedow noted, “New York’s artistic energy, support, scale and
audience for the arts of all disciplines, has always been a magnet for Boston’s artist community.”
3 Christine Temin, “The ICA at 60: Where does the museum fit in?” The Boston Globe, May 5, 1996.
4 Maureen Dezell, “ICA Faces Fund-raising Challenge,” The Boston Globe, March 10 2000.
TURNAROUND AND TRANSFORMATION: LEADERSHIP AND RISK AT BOSTON’S INSTITUTE OF
CONTEMPORARY ART
Cate Reavis
NOVEMBER 9, 2010 3
There were members of Boston’s art world that felt the absence of a strong contemporary art
community was a big drawback for Boston. As William Rawn, a Boston architect and long time ICA
board member, explained, “Artists provide a very different way of looking at the world. They ask
questions that are different from the norm and in Boston, a city that honors academics and inventors,
this is particularly admired.” Furthermore, through their work, contemporary artists reflected what
was currently happening in society and as Vin Cipolla, who served on the ICA board for 16 years and
as its chairman from 1997-2005, noted: “It’s the role of an institution like the ICA to provide a safe
place where a diversity of perspectives can be expressed to a wide audience.”
This was something Medvedow believed at her core.
Jill Medvedow
Described as “pathologically optimistic,” Jill Medvedow’s commitment to civic causes began when
she was young. Raised in New Haven, Connecticut, by parents who were political and social activists,
Medvedow admitted that campaigning was something she was exposed to in utero. “My parents
taught me how to be a good citizen,” she said. “My mother was deeply engaged in volunteering for
civic and charitable causes and my father was a prominent elected official. I grew up thinking I was
part of the city’s political fabric.”5 Through her upbringing, she “learned about the basic mechanics of
organizing and how to move an agenda,”6 skill sets that would serve her well in her professional life.
Trained as an art historian, Medvedow arrived in Boston in 1986 from Seattle where she had founded
a nonprofit contemporary arts center. In 1991 she became the first full-time contemporary curator at
the Isabella Stewart Gardner Museum, bringing in numerous performing and visual artists from
around the world. When she left the Gardner in 1996, Medvedow was determined that her next career
move would involve bringing art to a broader public. “I was trying to figure out how to build a bridge
between contemporary art and an audience that didn’t have a great affection for it,” she explained. “I
came up with the idea of framing public art projects through the history and landscape of Boston,
which Bostonians typically have a lot of affection for.” Within a year, she founded Vita Brevis, an
organization devoted to producing temporary public art pieces. With the first Vita Brevis project near
completion, Medvedow found herself being courted to become the ICA’s next director.
According to Rawn, who headed the search committee for the ICA’s new director, it was
Medvedow’s character as much as her curatorial background that made her such an attractive
candidate:
The minute you met Jill you immediately noticed that she is centered. She is not wowed by
trends. In language, in dress, she is not the least bit pretentious. She doesn’t try to be someone or
something she isn’t. She is not out to prove anything to anybody. She has a strong intellectual
5 Christine Temin, “Jill Medvedow’s Dreamscape…” The Boston Globe, July 15, 2001.
6 Rachel Strutt, “The Visionary Jill Medvedow…” The Boston Globe, December 31, 2006.
TURNAROUND AND TRANSFORMATION: LEADERSHIP AND RISK AT BOSTON’S INSTITUTE OF
CONTEMPORARY ART
Cate Reavis
NOVEMBER 9, 2010 4
base for her opinions on art. This part of her persona was reflected in her vision for the ICA,
which was something that really struck us. She was passionate that the ICA needed to be relevant,
very public and non-elitist, and that in order for it to succeed, it had to be better at outreach
whether it was with school children, local politicians, donors, or members.
A further selling point for the search committee was that because Medvedow was an outsider in the
world of museum directors, she didn’t come with old rivalries or attachments.
Striving to be Marginal
When Medvedow took the reigns in March 1998, the ICA, with a yearly attendance of 25,000 (an
average of 68 people a day) and a paltry budget just shy of $1 million, was in the midst of a severe
identity crisis. The museum was housed in a converted police station and stable on Boylston Street, a
building it had purchased from the city of Boston in the early 1990s with $328,000 in donations from
trustees and overseers.7 (The Boylston address was the 10th location the museum had had since its
founding.) The quirky space was largely defined by an enormous staircase that cut down through the
center of the building’s four floors, creating enormous space contraints for exhibits. Unlike other
Boston-area museums which could hang more than 10 shows a year,8 the ICA was limited to just
four, with months of down time in between shows. Partly because of space and largely because of
money and lack of interest, the ICA had no permanent collection, an important symbol of status in the
museum world, which also helped art institutions create an identity, draw repeat visitors, and build a
donor base. Meanwhile, contemporary art could be viewed at a number of museums throughout
Boston, many of which were backed by well-endowed academic institutions including MIT’s List
Visual Arts Center, the Rose Art Museum (Brandeis), Massachusetts College of Art, the Museum of
Fine Arts, and Harvard University Art Museums. As Medvedow liked to say at the time, “The ICA
was striving to be marginal.”
Medvedow’s mandate was to stabilize and reinvent. As Cipolla explained,
The ICA was doing some great work but it didn’t really have a point of view. The programming
was spotty, the outreach was not very strategic, and the building we were in was a physical
manifestation of the inadequacy of the organization. The ICA needed to be a place that, by the
nature of its work and outreach, touched multiple facets of the Boston community. In order to
become this, we needed somebody driven, entrepreneurial, who would be forceful about change.
One of the things that set Jill apart from the other candidates wasn’t that she had spent a lifetime
in contemporary art but rather than she understood how to work with audiences. She had the
passion to bring content and interactive thinking and approaches to people of all ages across a
spectrum of interests, getting the ICA outside of an elite and narrow comfort zone. She wasn’t
7 Christine Temin, “The ICA at 60: Where does the museum fit in?” The Boston Globe, May 5, 1996.
8 Ibid.
TURNAROUND AND TRANSFORMATION: LEADERSHIP AND RISK AT BOSTON’S INSTITUTE OF
CONTEMPORARY ART
Cate Reavis
NOVEMBER 9, 2010 5
willing to accept that what the ICA had to offer, or what contemporary artists had to say, was not
important for all kinds of people.
As part of her hiring agreement, Medvedow was allowed to bring Vita Brevis with her and fold it into
the ICA’s programming, a move that proved critical over the following years as the ICA strove to
reposition itself. As one journalist noted at the time, “Since the ICA has so much trouble pulling
people in, putting art where people will virtually have to trip over it may be a smart move.”9
Early Days
Shortly after her arrival, Medvedow put together a “business planning group” comprised of three
board members and three outsiders including Sheryl Marshall, who, as a top stockbroker, was a
known business leader in Boston; Nick Littlefield, a lawyer who had served as Senator Edward
Kennedy’s Chief of Staff for 10 years; and, Mary Schneider Enriquez, an art historian and critic who
had recently moved to Boston from Mexico City. (Marshall and Schneider Enriquez would eventually
join the ICA board.) With the help of the business planning group, Medvedow set out to disrupt the
unproductive conversations of the existing board about the future of the ICA. As Medvedow recalled,
“We looked at a number of questions. What kind of audience did we want? Did we want to stay small
and focused or did we want to broaden our offerings? What should be the role of education? We
explored questions involving content, specifically if we should become a collecting institution. And
finally we looked at whether we could do this work in our current Back Bay location.” It didn’t take
long for the group to decide that the ICA needed to grow its audience, expand its educational
initiatives, form a task force to look at the idea of collecting, and begin looking for a new space. (On
two separate occasions, directors of the ICA who preceded Medvedow explored relocating the
museum but were unable to garner board or community support.)
Medvedow’s attention then turned to learning about the Boston real estate market. While she didn’t
know if or how it would be possible, she was clear that the ICA needed to be located on the water:
“Our job is uniquely difficult in that Boston is not a city that embraces contemporary art. Since
everything about our work is unfamiliar, we’re always fighting for an audience. We needed to be
located on the water in order to attract people and motivate them to come back time and again. And a
waterfront location was also a perfect metaphor for what we do which is to expand horizons.”
After many months of knocking on doors to get information on Boston waterfront real estate,
Mevedow’s research picked up momentum when the Commissioner of Parks and Recreation, Justine
Liff, referred her to Ed Sidman, one of Boston’s big real estate developers and a major philanthopist.
Sidman suggested they meet in the lobby of his firm’s building as opposed to his office, a request
which sent an immediate negative signal to Medvedow. But she succeeded in flipping the switch:
9 Christine Temin, “Seeing the Light,” The Boston Globe, April 19, 1998.
TURNAROUND AND TRANSFORMATION: LEADERSHIP AND RISK AT BOSTON’S INSTITUTE OF
CONTEMPORARY ART
Cate Reavis
NOVEMBER 9, 2010 6
After listening to my pitch, he was ready to send me off with a name of the next person I should
talk to when I said to him, ‘You know, I swim in your pool at the Leventhal-Sidman Jewish
Community Center in Newton.’ And he says, ‘Oh really.’ And I say, ‘Yes, and I frequently go to
the openings in the center’s gallery.’ The next thing you know he’s saying, ‘Let’s go to my
office.’ So now we’re in his office and I’ve honed in on his passion which is how to get members
of a JCC to engage in Jewish continuity and not just athletics. We ended up having a deep,
intense conversation. The next thing I know, he has given me a couple good names to pursue for
waterfront real estate. And for the next couple of years, I meet with him regularly to advise him
on his project.
Following up on Sidman’s recommendations, Medvedow eventually landed a meeting with the
Boston 2000 committee. Put together by Mayor Thomas Menino to plan millenial activities for
Boston, one of the committee’s responsibilities was deciding who or what should be designated the
.75 acre parcel, also known as Parcel J, on Boston’s Fan Pier.
Little did she know, the committee would end up being Medvedow’s last stop in her real estate
search.
Fan Pier’s Parcel J
Described as “a wasteland of parking lots,”10 Parcel J was just a tiny sliver of the 21 acre, 3-million
square foot, nine-block industrial area owned by the Pritzker family, which was slated to be part of
the largest waterfront development in Boston’s history. The proposed plan was to populate the space
with 800 residential units, 1,000 hotel rooms, 150,000 square feet of civic and cultural space, parks
and open space, and an extension of a walkway along Boston Harbor.11 In a deal with the city of
Boston, which enabled them to expand the size of their proposed hotels,12 the Pritzkers agreed to
donate Parcel J to a cultural site.
Medvedow met with the Boston 2000 committee in the spring of 1999. It was a Thursday. Impressed
with her ideas for a future ICA on the waterfront, the committee suggested she present to the Boston
2000 subcommittee on Parcel J. Much to her disbelief, Medvedow found herself committing to giving
a formal, “this-is-what-we-have-in-mind” presentation the next Tuesday. As she recalled, “The
decision to go after the parcel was a big leap of faith. It was very hard to imagine we could make the
case given how weak we were.”
Scraping together $5,000, Medvedow hired an architect who drew a mock-up of a future ICA perched
on Parcel J. In giving the architect directives, Medvedow was concerned with one detail: that the
10 Geoff Edgers, “How They Did It,” The Boston Globe, December 6, 2006.
11 “Institute of Contemporary Art, Boston Announces Four Internationally Recognized Architecture Firms….” ICA Press Release, December 13, 2000.
12 It is not uncommon in commercial real estate for a developer to designate a parcel of land in exchange for being allowed to add height to a building as a way
to maximize revenue and earning potential.
TURNAROUND AND TRANSFORMATION: LEADERSHIP AND RISK AT BOSTON’S INSTITUTE OF
CONTEMPORARY ART
Cate Reavis
NOVEMBER 9, 2010 7
structure fit on the land that was available. Along with the mock-up, Medvedow and a couple ICA
staff members spent the weekend before the presentation making boards of eight museums — ranging
in size and cost from the Milwaukee Art Museum to Minneapolis’ Weisman Art Museum to the Getty
in Los Angeles — that had been built in different cities since the early 1990s. Their idea was to stress
the point that these museums had catapulted civic life and economic development in their respective
cities and had played an important role in urban rebirth.
Medvedow arrived on the designated Tuesday to present and found to her surprise that the ICA was
one of three finalists who were presenting. One of the other finalists, a collaboration involving the
Wang Center, Boston Ballet and Boston Lyric Opera, proposed a three-stage complex, described as a
cross between Sydney’s Opera House and New York’s Lincoln Center. The $100 million complex
would include a 2,400-seat opera and ballet house, a 500-700-seat playhouse, and a floating stage that
could accommodate an audience of 1,000. Due to its size, the complex was expected to exceed the
allotted space and would require some additional land that had been set aside by the Pritzkers for an
office tower. The other finalist was a relatively unknown Boston-area entrepreneur who wanted to
develop a $40 million Fan Pier Performing Arts and Film Center that would include a 700-seat recital
hall and 125-seat partially open-air theater.
In her pitch, Medvedow stressed that the new ICA would be “a public destination and the
architectural heartbeat of the city.”13 Funded by a $40 million capital campaign, the four-story
building would occupy 60,000 square feet and would include a 400-seat theater, and a roof sculpture
garden. It would hold up to 2,000 visitors. Medvedow left the presentation thinking that the museum
had a slim shot, at best, of winning Parcel J, but she was increasingly convinced that the waterfront
was the right location for a new ICA. The committee’s final decision would be announced in
November.
Drumming up Support
In the intervening six months, Medvedow got busy educating the public, particularly local politicians,
residents and area artists, on the ICA’s plans for a new home on Fan Pier. To help her sell the idea,
Medvedow approached Gloria Larson, who at the time was a partner at one of Boston’s premier law
firms who specialized in real estate development and government. At the time, Larson was chairman
of the board of the Convention Center Authority and was in the middle of her own campaign to get a
new convention center built in South Boston. As Larson explained, “I joined the ICA ‘campaign’ as
both a lawyer and an advocate. I felt like Jill and I were traveling down the same path together.”
In planning the campaign’s strategy, Larson recalled: “We asked ourselves, ‘Who do we need to
touch who normally won’t get touched in a process like this? Who would normally never support
building an ICA on South Boston’s waterfront?’” After a bit of reflection, Larson decided to visit a
couple of South Boston’s key political leaders. Larson took Medvedow to meet James Kelly, who at
13 Maureen Dezell, “ICA Faces Fund-raising Challenge,” The Boston Globe, March 10 2000.
TURNAROUND AND TRANSFORMATION: LEADERSHIP AND RISK AT BOSTON’S INSTITUTE OF
CONTEMPORARY ART
Cate Reavis
NOVEMBER 9, 2010 8
the time was the city council’s president, state senator Stephen Lynch, and state representative Jack
Hart, all of whom she knew from her law practice and her work on the convention center. The
purpose of the meeting was to educate them on the ICA’s development plans and to hear their
concerns.
After introductions, Kelly began the conversation by saying, “You can’t tell us you’re going to build
a contemporary art museum next to Southie.” Medvedow responded by saying, “Let me tell you about
it. Let me tell you about the programs we have and how I want to bring kids from South Boston in,
and how the world of art is an opportunity to expand their horizons in ways that I know you would
support.” Hearing her out, Kelly’s concerns turned to the infamous Robert Mapplethorpe exhibit.
Shown at the ICA in the early 1990s, the exhibit caused great controversy for its sexually explicit
photographs. “You have to promise me you will never do a show like that again,” Kelly stated.
Medvedow retorted with: “You know I can’t make that promise. That would be like me asking you to
promise that you’ll never do anything controversial again. But how about I promise you that if I’m
going to do anything like that, I will give you notice so that you won’t be caught by surprise.” Kelly
quickly responded with, “Well if you ever do anything like that I will organize a picket.” “Well if you
organize a picket,” Medvedow said, “I’ll bring you coffee, because that kind of attention is exactly
what we need to build an audience for the ICA in Boston.” It was at this point in the exchange that
Kelly turned to Larson and said, “Larson, I like your friend Jill.”
In November 1999 the Boston 2000 committee announced that the ICA had won the Parcel J
competition. Medvedow believed one of the main reasons the ICA was chosen was because the
mock-up demonstrated that from a space perspective, the museum would be a perfect fit. In addition,
the ICA had successfully proven its financial viability to the committee by identifying $12 million—
of which $6 million would come from the sale of its Boylston building—of the estimated $40 million
needed for the project. Larson believed that Medvedow’s ability to assess her audience before sharing
her vision was key to sealing the deal. “She had a way of presenting to large and small audiences the
concept of a new ICA so that it became something they could own too. She was able to tell the story
in ways that each audience could hear.”
Of course, there were many skeptics of the committee’s decision and the ICA’s plan. Some thought
that locating the ICA away from other cultural attractions was a mistake. After all, it had not been
able to attract visitors when it was located in the heart of Boston’s tourist district. Then there was the
whole issue of money, something the ICA had little of and had no history of raising. While the land
was free, the building and operational costs would more than test the museum’s fundraising
capabilities. As Paul Buttenwieser, ICA board member and Boston philanthropist, put it, “The key
question is whether the wider community of philanthropic and arts supporters will see this as a
credible project they want to be involved with.”14
14 Maureen Dezell, “ICA Faces Fund-Raising Challenge,” The Boston Globe, March 10, 2000.
TURNAROUND AND TRANSFORMATION: LEADERSHIP AND RISK AT BOSTON’S INSTITUTE OF
CONTEMPORARY ART
Cate Reavis
NOVEMBER 9, 2010 9
But then there were those who were quietly cheering for the ICA. As one Boston Globe journalist
pointed out, “While informed observers think it unlikely the ICA will realize its goals, an unusual
number hold out hope that it will. In a city better known for its enthusiasm for sports, politics and
revenge than for boosterism, optimists and cynics admire the organization for attempting to defy the
formidable odds against building something innovative in Boston.”15
And then there was the ICA’s biggest cheerleader. As Larson noted, “Jill believed in the vision
herself. She had no doubt that it could be done.”
Now What?
After winning the right to build on Parcel J, one of Medvedow’s first orders of business was to hire a
director of development, a position that had not previously existed at the ICA. A consultant
Medvedow had hired to help develop a fundraising and endowment strategy suggested she talk to the
MFA’s marketing director Paul Bessire. This same consultant, however, warned Medvedow that
Bessire would never leave the MFA for the ICA. She wanted to talk to him nevertheless.
Meeting over a drink, Medvedow and Bessire connnected immediately after discovering they lived in
the same neighborhood and their kids went to the same school. When the conversation turned to the
purpose of their meeting Medvedow was blunt: “Why,” she asked, “would you rather stay at the MFA
than be a part of making something totally new that could reshape how the city of Boston thinks
about contemporary art?”
By spring 2000, Bessire was the ICA’s new Director of External Relations. Shortly after his arrival
the ICA launched a $50 million “Campaign for the New ICA” — which eventually grew to $62
million — on the back of $6 million that had been committed by two ICA trustees. As Bessire
explained, launching a campaign with far less than 50% of funds already raised was a very
unconventional strategy, but it was one that made sense for an organization that wanted to send a
message to the community: “The strategy was to demonstrate that there was a commitment on the
part of the board and the institution to make this project happen and a good fundraising strategy
always begins with the family.”
In concert with developing a fundraising strategy and finding and hiring the right talent to oversee it,
Medvedow was eager to bring in new blood—which was to say business leaders with clout16 —to the
ICA’s 35-member board, and ease out those whose vision was not aligned with where she was taking
the museum. Success in winning the rights to the land coupled with Medvedow’s vision of investing
in Boston’s future as opposed to its past, Bessire noted, had put the ICA in a very different light in the
eyes of potential board members. By early 2001, there were 13 new members, the majority of whom
15 Maureen Dezell, “ICA Faces Fund-Raising Challenge,” The Boston Globe, March 10, 2000.
16 Geoff Edgers, “How They Did It,” The Boston Globe, December 6, 2006.
TURNAROUND AND TRANSFORMATION: LEADERSHIP AND RISK AT BOSTON’S INSTITUTE OF
CONTEMPORARY ART
Cate Reavis
NOVEMBER 9, 2010 10
came from the private equity, venture capital, and financial services sector. (See Exhibit 1 for list of
those who joined the ICA board between 1998 and 2001.)
Although Medvedow’s to-do list after winning the rights to build on Parcel J was populated with
tasks relating to the museum’s future home, she never lost site of the importance of not only keeping
the ICA up and running—and this included bringing in high-profile artists like Cornelia Parker,
Olafur Eliasson, and Ellen Gallagher, and sponsoring public art projects such as Art on the Emerald
Necklace that received national recognition—but publicly repositioning the ICA by building
excitement for its future and demonstrating the legitimate need for a new building. As Rawn noted, “I
cite this as one of the most notable elements of Jill’s leadership. Too often you see institutions plunge
ahead on a new capital investment and they really let the existing institution wither and put
themselves at risk for not succeeding in the new place.”
One of the most notable ways Medvedow involved the public in the future ICA was in the selection
of architects.
Selecting an Architect
The ICA began its architect search with a couple of basic criteria. As Cipolla explained in early 2001,
“We want an architect with a deep understanding of the civic. This is not just a building, not just an
interior showcase. It has a civic role. A lot depends on what happens outside the four walls.”17 In
addition, Medvedow noted that the museum was looking for an individual or a firm that had not
completed a prominent building in the United States: “The ICA has a long tradition of supporting the
work of emerging artists.”18
The ICA traveled down a fairly unconventional path when it came to the actual selection process.
Instead of following the typical competition approach whereby a select number of firms would be
paid an agreed upon sum of money to come up with a specific proposal, Medvedow decided on a
different course of action. She explained:
One of our board members who was an architect said to me, ‘Be careful about competitions
because you get what you pay for. In order to have a healthy competition, you will need to offer
up significant funds so that architects will invest the time it will take to come up with smart, well
thought through proposals.’ So, we decided not to do a competition because we were certain we
didn’t have the money. And given that we’re in the business of reviewing artists’ work over time
we felt that we could judge the work of architects ourselves.
With that decision made, Medvedow put together an Architect Selection Committee. Headed by Nick
Pritzker, the committee included Medvedow, Cipolla, Henrique de Campos Meirelles, President of
17 Robert Campbell, “Designers Vie for a Shot at the ICA,” The Boston Globe, March 22, 2001.
18 Robert Campbell, “A Vision Fulfilled at Harbor’s Edge,” The Boston Globe, December 1, 2006.
TURNAROUND AND TRANSFORMATION: LEADERSHIP AND RISK AT BOSTON’S INSTITUTE OF
CONTEMPORARY ART
Cate Reavis
NOVEMBER 9, 2010 11
Fleet Global Banking, Barbara Lee, Vice Chair of the Board of Trustees and philanthropist, and Ellen
Poss, Vice Chair of the Board of Trustees and philanthropist. Medvedow decided not to include any
architects in the group, as she didn’t want the committee to be driven by any one architectural agenda.
The committee’s first assignment was to establish goals and criteria, which would help guide the ICA
through the selection process. To help the committee, which had no baseline knowledge of
architecture, Medvedow hired an architectural historian from Harvard University to lead a seminar on
contemporary architecture for the group. The historian helped the committee establish goals and
criteria (Exhibit 2), and drew up a list of 30 architectural firms for consideration.
Using the list of goals and criteria as a guide, the committee scaled down the list of 30 firms to twelve
and ultimately to four. The chosen four included Studio Granda from Iceland, Boston-based Office
d’A, Peter Zumthor of Switerland, and Diller + Scofidio from New York. Medvedow traveled to meet
the four firms and each was invited to Boston to present their work to the committee.
Medvedow recognized that in order for the ICA to matter to a wider audience, more people had to be
involved in the dialogue on the ICA’s building plans. On March 24, 2001, the ICA hosted “Building
A Vision: Four Architects’ Views”, a public presentation at the Copley Theater where the final four
firms were asked to present. Medvedow laid down one rule for the presenters: because the purpose of
the presentation was to enable the firms to show their work and discuss their philosophies towards
contemporary art, they were not to present their ideas for building a new ICA. She explained her
reasoning: “The minute there’s an image out there of what architect X could create I feared that I
would have to manage a multitude of stakeholders who were wedded to architect X’s proposal. But
what if we didn’t choose that proposal or what if we chose it and it substantially changed during the
design process? I didn’t want to be caught in that kind of public negativity.”
The presentations drew an impressive crowd. “People were literally waiting in line to get in,”
Medvedow recalled. “There was not an unfilled seat in the theater. This level of transparency in
museum planning had never happened before in Boston. There was enormous enthusiasm behind our
out-of-the-box, if not downright off-the-wall project, and the public was thrilled that we wanted to
share our ideas. In addition there was great excitement over what might happen down on the
waterfront.” While not responsible for the ultimate decision, attendees were queried on their thoughts
through a survey with questions that included: What did you like about the work presented? What do
you think are some of the most important design opportunities provided by the waterfront site? Do
you find any of the architects’ design philosophies to be particularly responsive to the institutional
mission of the ICA?19
Of the four presenters, Peter Zumthor and Diller + Scofidio stood out as much for their work as for
their general philosophy towards architecture.
19 Robert Campbell, “Designers Vie for a Shot at the ICA,” The Boston Globe, March 22, 2001.
TURNAROUND AND TRANSFORMATION: LEADERSHIP AND RISK AT BOSTON’S INSTITUTE OF
CONTEMPORARY ART
Cate Reavis
NOVEMBER 9, 2010 12
Diller + Scofidio
Winners of the MacArthur Foundation “genius” grant in 1999—marking the first time architects had
been awarded the grant—the husband and wife team of Richard Scofidio and Elizabeth Diller was
known for integrating media and architecture. As Diller stated during their presentation, “Architecture
and new technologies need not be adversaries. The union can actually be quite fertile.”
Diller + Scofidio’s resume was quite deep when it came to the work they had done on the inside of
museum walls. They had worked with many visual and performing artists and had completed
numerous art installations. Their most well known indoor architectural work was the renovation of the
Brasserie restaurant located in the Seagram building in New York. As Diller explained, one of their
goals in redesigning the space was to find ways to connect the restaurant, which was below ground
and without natural light, back to the street. They accomplished this by getting a blurred video
snapshot of every person as they came through the revolving door. The image was displayed above
the bar, with every new entrance image pushing the previous 15 to the right. (See Exhibit 3.)
When it came to building, however, their resume was quite thin; in fact they had never built a
building in the United States. Their most renowned work was the Blur Building, a media pavilion
built for the 2002 Swiss Expo in Neuchatal, which was less a building and more a suspended platform
enveloped by a man-made cloud of fog. (See Exhibit 4.) Blur, which was a temporary structure
where no one lived or worked, showcased Diller + Scofidio’s belief that “architecture must always
question material and spatial conventions.”
Peter Zumthor
Of the four finalists, Peter Zumthor was the best known and the most experienced architect, with the
art museum in Bregenz, Austria (Kunsthaus Bregenz) and the thermal baths (Therme Vals) in
Switzerland being two of his most famous works. (See Exhibits 5 and 6.) As one journalist wrote,
“Although [Zumthor] cultivates the disarming role of simple artisan-architect, he is responsible for
some of the most radical buildings of our time. His sophisticated, demanding, exquisite structures of
rigidly reductive minimalism, in which every detail has enormous aesthetic and emotional power,
create their own world of Zen-like, concentrated beauty – an immutable perfectionism that probably
scares off as many clients as it attracts.”20
Zumthor was not known for a particular style, but, as one observer noted, a number of themes were
interwoven throughout much of his work: celebration of place, engagement of all the human senses,
deep understanding of space, light and materiality.21 For Zumthor, architecture “[had] it’s own realm.
20 Ada Louise Huxtable, “Architecture’s Best Kept Secrets,” Wall Street Journal, May 15, 2001.
21 Peter Davey, “Zumthor the Shaman,” Architectrual Review, October 1, 1998.
TURNAROUND AND TRANSFORMATION: LEADERSHIP AND RISK AT BOSTON’S INSTITUTE OF
CONTEMPORARY ART
Cate Reavis
NOVEMBER 9, 2010 13
It has a special physical relationship with life. I do not think of it primarily as either a message or a
symbol, but as an envelope and background for life which goes on in and around it…”22
While his work was renowned, so was his need to control. “I like to control the buildings I do,” he
admitted to the crowd gathered in the Copley Theater. During his presentation Zumthor recounted his
frustration towards a project he was awarded in Berlin that was never complete: “This was eight
damned years ago and for eight years these people wanted me to make compromises and
compromises,” he explained showing great frustration, and giving members of the Architect Selection
Committee some pause.23
Decision
In April 2001, the ICA announced that Diller + Scofidio had been chosen to build the new building.
Liz Diller believed they were tapped because of their belief that there needed to be a partnership
between the new building and the art it would house: “From the beginning we said neither would play
a supporting role for the other.” From Medvedow’s perspective, while the choice of Diller + Scofidio
was motivated largely by their “sheer brilliance,” there was another important reason: “Because they
didn’t have a lot of experience they had as much to gain as we did, and consequently as much to lose
as we did. So we all had as much at stake to make it work.”
By the time the ICA broke ground in September 2004, half of the $62 million had been committed,
the majority coming from the ICA’s board of trustees and corporate donors. Once again, the ICA was
relying on an unconventional and risky development strategy. As Bessire explained, “Development
people always say the minute you break ground, people assume it’s a done deal and will be reluctant
to give money. We broke ground and people started believing in us.”
Stumbling Blocks
The ICA faced several major challenges in its effort to erect a new home on Fan Pier. As Medvedow
explained, building a new waterfront property in Boston was an “arduous” task when it came to
obtaining all the required state and city approvals. In fact the ICA had to get dozens of approvals,
worth millions of dollars in legal fees, between the time it was granted the land and when it opened its
doors in 2006. As Medvedow noted, the ICA’s ability to navigate these waters was surprising to
many: “A lot of people thought that even though we had gotten the land, the process of getting all the
approvals would end up killing us. We learned quickly who we needed to talk to and convince to
grant us the approvals we needed.”
Just months away from breaking ground on the building, the Pritzker family’s development plans for
the 21 acre lot surrounding the ICA were aborted. The family announced in late 2003 that it would be
putting the land up for sale. Honoring the commitments they made to the city of Boston, the Pritzkers
22 Peter Davey, “Zumthor the Shaman,” Architectrual Review, October 1, 1998.
23 Geoff Edgers, “How They Did It,” The Boston Globe, December 6, 2006.
TURNAROUND AND TRANSFORMATION: LEADERSHIP AND RISK AT BOSTON’S INSTITUTE OF
CONTEMPORARY ART
Cate Reavis
NOVEMBER 9, 2010 14
let it be known publicly that the new buyer would have to agree to the building commitments they
made to the city of Boston, including setting aside the .75 acre parcel for the ICA.24 The Pritzker’s
decision was a big disappointment for the ICA. As Medvedow noted, “We lost a partner that
recognized the ICA as an asset.”
Finally, in April 2006, just five months before the new building was scheduled to open, the ICA faced
another major change. Macomber, a 100-year old construction firm that was considered one of
Boston’s leading builders, had fallen months behind schedule and was dealing with the legal
aftermath of a recent accident on one of its construction sites which claimed three lives. The ICA
responded by bringing in another firm to complete the work. In August, Medvedow announced that
because of construction delays the ICA would have to delay its September opening. In explaining the
postponement, Medvedow told The Boston Globe, “Our building is beautiful, it’s close to completion,
and it works. But you only get one chance to make a first impression. When we open, we are going to
hit the ground running. In the long life of this building, this is a very insignificant and brief hiccup.”25
On December 10, 2006, the new ICA opened to more than 8,000 visitors. (See Exhibit 7.)
If They Build It, Will They Come?
The ICA’s ability to oversee the construction of a new building on Boston’s waterfront by an
architecture firm that had never built a building in the United States, raise over $75 million—
surpassing the capital campaign goal of $62 million—and welcome over 280,000 visitors in its first
year—well over the 200,000 that was needed to break even—was, in most people’s minds,
miraculous. The question posed by one museum director a year before the new ICA opened its doors,
“Do you really think there are five times the market for the ICA’s program than there is right now and
that the only reason they’re not getting them now is building size?”26 had been answered “yes”.
But sustaining the attendance level would be the main challenge going forward. New museums
tended to attract huge crowds in their first year of operation only to see attendance taper off. San
Francisco’s Museum of Modern Art, which opened its new building in 1995 saw its attendance soar
from 250,000 to 800,000 in its first year, and then come back down to 600,000 in its second year. The
Peabody Essex Museum in Massachusetts more than doubled its attendance in year one only to see it
decline in year two. As that museum’s deputy director stated, “The first year [attendance] doesn’t
matter. It’s everybody looking at it because it’s there. The ‘lookyloos,’ I like to call them.”27
But in the case of the ICA, the ‘lookyloos’ seemed to be holding their gaze. In 2008 and 2009, the
ICA had a combined attendance record of well over 450,000.
24 Thomas Palmer, “Fan Pier Site up for Sale,” The Boston Globe, December 19. 2003.
25 Geoff Edgers, “Museum Sees Weeks-Long Construction Delay,” The Boston Globe, August 4, 2006.
26 Geoff Edgers, “Under Construction: An Arts Renaissance,” The Boston Globe, April 10, 2005.
27 Ibid.
TURNAROUND AND TRANSFORMATION: LEADERSHIP AND RISK AT BOSTON’S INSTITUTE OF
CONTEMPORARY ART
Cate Reavis
NOVEMBER 9, 2010 15
Exhibit 1 New Additions to the ICA Board (1998-2001)
Pat Stavaridis, Art Collector
Sheryl Marshall, Vice President, Donaldson, Lufkin and Jenrette
Vivien Hassenfeld, Designer, Hasbro
Mary Schneider Enriquez, art critic and independent curator
Henrique de Campos Meirelles, President and Chief Operating Officer, Bank of Boston
Robert Davoli, Sigma Partners
Charles Rodgers, Chairman, WFD Consulting
Andrew Goldfarb, Managing Director, JAFCO America Ventures
Anthony Terrana, oral surgeon
Tim Ferguson, Senior Managing Partner, Putnam Investments
Jonathan Seelig, Co-Founder, Akamai
Nicholas Adams, Senior Vice President, Partner and Equity Portfolio Manager,
Wellington Management
Jean-Francois Formela, Investment Principal, Atlas Venture Capital
Source: ICA.
TURNAROUND AND TRANSFORMATION: LEADERSHIP AND RISK AT BOSTON’S INSTITUTE OF
CONTEMPORARY ART
Cate Reavis
NOVEMBER 9, 2010 16
Exhibit 2 Goals and Criteria for New ICA
Goals
Architectural
Advancement
For almost 65 years, the Institute of Contemporary Art has played a pivotal
international role as a vanguard institution by championing new artistic practice
and delivering innovative programming. The ICA’s new building should advance
architectural thought and practice, reflecting the artistic mission of the ICA.
A Powerful
Visitor
Experience
The architect selected to design the new ICA should demonstrate a sensitivity to
the exhibition and interpretation of contemporary art and to providing a powerful
visitor experience. Through programs, architecture, education and technology, the
new ICA should provide future generations with access to the finest examples of
creativity, learning and inspiration.
Civic
Responsibility
The new ICA will be a visual and physical destination for Bostonians and visitors
alike, and a cornerstone of the new Fan Pier. It will relate to the intimate scale of
individual human beings while responding to the unique character of its urban
context and waterfront location. The chosen architect should have a sense of
responsibility to the public realm and a capacity to create a building with
international public significance for Boston’s 21st century.
Criteria
Advances an architectural vision for the future
Creates a building whose presence can shape the waterfront
Innovates spatially
Scales building to human proportions
Shapes and uses natural light well
Attends to detail and construction
Possesses a vision of the museum’s public role in the city
Focuses on only a few, important projects
Respects the ICA’s professional and financial resources
Has a career trajectory where a breakthrough building is likely
Source: ICA.
TURNAROUND AND TRANSFORMATION: LEADERSHIP AND RISK AT BOSTON’S INSTITUTE OF
CONTEMPORARY ART
Cate Reavis
NOVEMBER 9, 2010 17
Exhibit 3 The Brasserie
Source: Diller + Scofidio
TURNAROUND AND TRANSFORMATION: LEADERSHIP AND RISK AT BOSTON’S INSTITUTE OF
CONTEMPORARY ART
Cate Reavis
NOVEMBER 9, 2010 18
Exhibit 4 Blur Building, Swiss Expo
Source: Diller + Scofidio
TURNAROUND AND TRANSFORMATION: LEADERSHIP AND RISK AT BOSTON’S INSTITUTE OF
CONTEMPORARY ART
Cate Reavis
NOVEMBER 9, 2010 19
Exhibit 5 Kunsthaus Bregenz
Source: Hans Peter Schaefer.
TURNAROUND AND TRANSFORMATION: LEADERSHIP AND RISK AT BOSTON’S INSTITUTE OF
CONTEMPORARY ART
Cate Reavis
NOVEMBER 9, 2010 20
Exhibit 6 Therme Vals (Thermal Baths)
Source: Roland Zumbüh.
TURNAROUND AND TRANSFORMATION: LEADERSHIP AND RISK AT BOSTON’S INSTITUTE OF
CONTEMPORARY ART
Cate Reavis
NOVEMBER 9, 2010 21
Exhibit 7 The New ICA
Source: Christopher Peterson.

good answer

good answer

good answer

1. Disney World in Florida wants to expand onto a Wetland. It has offered to buy and
preserve a large nature preserve in a different area to make up for the wetland it is
destroying. Based on what you have learned about wetlands, is that reasonable? What
conditions would make it reasonable or unreasonable?
Suppose further that the wetland being destroyed and its replacement area both contain
several endangered species (but different ones). How would you compare different
species against each other? How many plant or insect species would one animal species
be worth?
2. Suppose a hurricane blows down most of the trees in a forest. Timber company
officials offer to salvage the fallen trees and replant a tree plantation to reduce the
chances of fire and to improve the area's appearance. In return, they want an agreement
that they can harvest the trees when they mature and plant another tree farm. Others argue
that the damaged forest should be left alone because hurricanes and other natural events
are part of nature and the dead trees will serve as a source of nutrients for natural
recovery through ecological succession. What do you think should be done and why?